Making the Right Roofing Choice for Oklahoma City’s Climate: Tile vs. Shingle Roofs

by | Aug 23, 2023 | Blog | 0 comments

Regarding homeownership, few decisions are as pivotal as choosing the suitable roofing material, especially in a climate as diverse and challenging as Oklahoma City’s. In this bustling metropolis, where scorching summers, torrential thunderstorms, and occasional ice storms are par for the course, your roofing choice can significantly impact your home’s longevity and comfort. Two contenders stand out among the array of roofing options: the classic elegance of tile roofs and the versatile practicality of shingle roofs. In this article, we delve into the crucial factors that define the investment value of these roofing choices, assisting homeowners in making well-informed decisions that cater to their unique needs.

Understanding the Climate in Oklahoma City

Oklahoma City’s weather patterns are dynamic, presenting homeowners with various roof challenges. The relentless summer sun, the fury of severe thunderstorms, and the occasional winter ice storm all demand roofing materials that can withstand various meteorological trials. Therefore, the choice of roofing material isn’t just a matter of aesthetics; it’s a matter of ensuring your home’s longevity, resilience, and safety against the backdrop of these weather fluctuations.

Tile Roof: Pros and Cons as an Investment

Advantages of Tile Roofing

Durability and Longevity:  One of the standout features of tile roofs is their durability. They’re renowned for withstanding the test of time and weather, often outlasting other roofing materials by decades. Their ability to endure heavy rains, high winds, and even hailstorms makes them a formidable option for homeowners seeking a long-lasting solution.

Aesthetic Appeal and Architectural Styles: Tile roofs offer a timeless aesthetic appeal that can elevate the visual charm of any home. They come in various styles, from Spanish and Mediterranean to modern, allowing homeowners to tailor their choice to the architectural style of their house.

Fire Resistance: In a region prone to wildfires, the fire-resistant properties of tile roofs can provide homeowners with peace of mind and an added layer of safety for their families and property.

Disadvantages of Tile Roofing

High Initial Costs: One notable downside of tile roofs is their higher upfront costs than more conventional roofing materials. This initial investment can deter budget-conscious homeowners, even though the long-term benefits often offset this initial expense.

Weight and Structural Considerations: The sturdy nature of tile roofs translates to a considerable weight, which can necessitate structural modifications to support the added load. This factor should be considered, as it could contribute to the overall installation costs.

Maintenance and Repairs: While tile roofs are remarkably durable, maintenance and repairs can be more intricate and labor-intensive. Specialized expertise may be required, potentially adding to the long-term costs of upkeep.

Shingle Roof: Pros and Cons as an Investment

Advantages of Shingle Roofing

Cost-Effectiveness: Shingle roofs present a cost-effective option for homeowners seeking a reliable roofing solution that won’t break the bank. They provide a balance between quality and affordability.

Variety of Styles and Colors: Shingle roofs offer a wide array of styles, colors, and textures, enabling homeowners to find the perfect fit for their home’s exterior. This versatility ensures that your roof can extend your style.

Ease of Installation: Shingle roofs are relatively straightforward to install, which can translate to reduced labor costs and shorter installation times than more complex roofing materials.

Disadvantages of Shingle Roofing

Limited Lifespan: Shingle roofs typically have a shorter lifespan than tile roofs. While they offer immediate cost savings, homeowners must factor in the potential need for more frequent replacements.

Susceptibility to Weather Damage: Intense weather conditions, such as heavy winds, hail, and rapid temperature fluctuations, can contribute to the deterioration of shingle roofs over time. This susceptibility may lead to more frequent repairs.

Lower Insulation and Energy Efficiency: Shingle roofs generally offer less insulation and energy efficiency than their tile counterparts. This could result in higher energy bills and a less comfortable indoor environment.

Considering the Local Factors

Impact of Oklahoma City’s Climate on Roofing Materials

Tile Roof’s Resistance to High Winds and Hailstorms: The durability of tile roofs makes them particularly well-suited to Oklahoma City’s high winds and occasional hailstorms. Their ability to withstand these challenges can provide homeowners with added peace of mind during turbulent weather.

Shingle Roof’s Adaptability to Temperature Fluctuations: Shingle roofs can expand and contract with temperature fluctuations, a common occurrence in Oklahoma City’s variable climate. This adaptability contributes to their resilience.

Local Building Codes and Regulations

Restrictions on Roofing Materials: Local regulations and homeowner association guidelines may dictate certain restrictions on roofing materials. Understanding these rules is crucial when making your roofing choice.

Energy Efficiency Requirements: Given the growing emphasis on energy efficiency, some areas might have requirements or incentives for energy-efficient roofing materials. This can influence your decision-making process.

Financial Considerations: Short-Term and Long-Term

Initial Costs Comparison

Cost of Materials: Tile roofs come with a higher upfront cost due to their quality and longevity. Shingle roofs, on the other hand, present a more budget-friendly option at the outset.

Installation Expenses: The installation process for tile roofs can be more complex and labor-intensive, potentially leading to higher installation costs. Shingle roofs, with their ease of installation, are more straightforward.

Longevity and Maintenance Costs

Lifespan of Tile vs. Shingle Roofs: While the initial investment in a tile roof may be higher, their extended lifespan often makes them a cost-effective choice in the long run. Shingle roofs may require more frequent replacements over time.

Repair and Replacement Costs: Tile roofs’ Maintenance and repair costs are generally lower than shingle roofs. This difference can further contribute to the cost-effectiveness of tile roofs over their lifetime.

Resale Value and Curb Appeal

The choice of roofing material can significantly impact the resale value of your property. A well-maintained tile or shingle roof not only enhances the aesthetics of your home but also contributes to the overall appeal for potential buyers. In the competitive real estate market of Oklahoma City, an attractive and durable roof can make a substantial difference.

Environmental Impact and Sustainability

The environmental aspect of roofing choices should be noticed. Tile roofs, with their extended lifespan and minimal waste, align with sustainable practices. On the other hand, shingle roofs can contribute to energy efficiency and insulation benefits that positively impact the environment.


In the vast realm of roofing choices, the interplay of elegance and practicality becomes most evident when considering the contrasting options of tile and shingle roofs. The decision-making process is nuanced and multifaceted, considering factors such as climate adaptation, financial considerations, and long-term sustainability. Each homeowner’s priorities and needs are unique, emphasizing the importance of consulting professionals to ensure a choice that aligns with practicality and personal style. Ultimately, whether it’s the enduring allure of tile or the practical charm of shingles, the chosen roof is a testament to careful consideration and a commitment to a secure, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasing home.

Recent Posts